Who is going to pay for Last.Fm?

No, really. It’s not an hypothesis: Last.Fm has just announced that it will charge  users (outside of US, UK and Germany) 3€/month to listen to its radio.

It’s easy to relate this news to the article by the Economist that announced the end of the free model online*, but ultimately this may just prove how wrong that article was.

The first reaction we can have is that Last.Fm made a stupid mistake, for three reasons:

  1. It’s not something you do now that Spotify is getting mainstream and seems likely to make it big
  2. It’s not something you do in those countries where Last.Fm is less penetrated, and use of the internet is less evolved. If you had a choice, you would probably charge american and english consumers,  because they best understand the value of Last.Fm, and if they’ve been using it for a while there may be an inherent cost in opting out and switching to another service (ie. getting familiar with the new service, reinstating your preferences…). Hopefully that cost would be psychologically higher than 3€/month.
  3. It’s not something you do, period. Digital music is free. Not because it’s a viable business model. Simply because it can be. And people would rather have it for free, than pay for it.

These considerations are so obvious that we must assume Last.Fm simply had no other choice. Let’s see what more will come out of this…


Final Burp: Back when Napster was shut down, I was wondering why Shawn Fanning didn’t just move the servers to another country where he wouldn’t face serious legal threats. Still wondering…


* If you read the article, here’s my comment:

“There’s a fundamental mistake in the article.

Freeconomics did not happen as a business strategy aimed at making money. It happened because: a) technology enables users to “get stuff” for free; b) a certain number of people globally are willing to create and distribute such technology for free.

Whether this is a sustainable business model or not is irrilevant, because Napster, BitTorrent, Linux, Wikipedia, Facebook and many others were not born to be businesses. If their attempts to make money gets in the way of user experience, somebody in the world will come up with a free alternative, and that’s where users will flow to.

The trick is, one person in the world is enough to create a free alternative available to a global audience.”


3 responses to “Who is going to pay for Last.Fm?

  1. Digital music is not free. Some people have sacrificed their whole lives to make it. I’m one of them.
    Do you work 40 hours a week and not receive a paycheck because your boss thinks you should work for free? When you test drive a new car and find the one you like do you just not go back to the dealership and drive away with it instead?
    But then again I doubt that lastfm will pay it’s artists, so far it’s been all lies. How they could ever have every artist in the world on their site and think they can pay them suffiently is beyond me.

  2. Hi J,

    I’m not saying that music comes effortless, nor that musicians should do it for free. What I’m saying is that people are not willing to pay to download tracks, and no law can change that, because technology would find a way around it. That implies that Last.FM could as well pay artists, but they have to work really hard to deliver a service that users will be willing to pay for in the first place. In absence of that, the bad news is that artists have to come up with new and diverse revenue streams, or we’ll lose a lot of them.
    The good news is that a lot of the cost that you, as an artist, had to sustain are not there anymore.

  3. Listenforfree

    But the thing is.. Last.fm has tons of songs are NOT because they purchased those songs, instead, they were uploaded by user all over the world. So basically they are fukin the audience who fill their database. so It’s a pure greed indeed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s